This study examines player attitudes towards religious worldviews in games like BioShock and Assassin's Creed on internet forums, focusing on the theological and technological factors influencing these discussions. Using a multi-method approach, including 91 discussions and 20 interviews, the research identifies various user attitudes, some of which seek enchantment amidst secularization. These attitudes are analyzed within the context of theological affordances of games and technological affordances of internet forums.