Serbian is a unique example of active digraphia, where both Cyrillic and Latin scripts are used by the same speech community. This paper examines the choice of alphabet and the use of non-standard orthographic variants on two Serbian news websites, Politika Online and B92. The study reveals a two-fold process in Serbian orthographic practices emerging from online discourse: the dominance of the Latin alphabet over Cyrillic and the stabilization of non-standard Latin orthographic variants. Metalinguistic commentaries from online users highlight the tension between pragmatic concerns and language ideologies.